Saturday, March 9, 2019

Darklands Puzzle #11

The path is blocked by an iron door. Above the door is carved:
ONE STATUE ALWAYS LIES, ONE SPEAKS ONLY TRUTH AND THE THIRD SPEAKS BOTH TRUTH AND LIES.
MULTIPLE SOLUTIONS ARE POSSIBLE.
TO OPEN THE DOOR, TOUCH THE ONE THAT CANNOT BE HARDGREP.
The three statues seem to have recently been shuffled around. They speak:
Gold says, "I am Tifsyn. Silver is Hardgrep."
Silver says. "True, gold is Tifsyn. However, I myself am Gymer."
Copper says. "Not so. Gold is Gymer."
You touch...
...the gold statue.
...the silver statue.
...the copper statue.
(Source: Darklands cluebook by MicroProse Software)

The cluebook has the hint "If Gold lies, then Silver cannot be the truth-teller." which was quite useful. If Gold lies then he is not Tifsyn and Silver is the intermediate sort of character (hereafter referred to simply as "the intermediate") who tells one truth and one lie, making him Gymer. This then means that Copper is also a "knave", which is not possible in this case, so this possibility can be disregarded entirely.

On the other hand, if Gold is the intermediate, then either:
  • Gold is Tifsyn and Silver is not Hardgrep or
  • Gold is not Tifsyn and Silver is Hardgrep
I will not make a further examination of whether Gold even can be the intermediate, like I did in the previous instance of considering whether Gold can be the "knave" because it's already clear that Gold can't be Hardgrep in this instance.

The final possibility that Gold is the "knight" leads to the trivial inference that Gold is not Hardgrep because Silver is. Accordingly, touch the gold statue.

Thursday, March 7, 2019

Darklands Puzzle #10

A door blocks the path. An inscription reads:
FACES ALWAYS LIE OR ALWAYS SPEAK TRUTH.
TOUCH ONE KNOB TO OPEN THE DOOR.
On the wall are six numbered faces, who speak:
One: "Gold opens the door."
Two: "Face One speaks truth. Copper cannot open the door."
Three: "Face Four is a liar."
Four: "Face Six is a liar. Face Six and myself are the only two liars."
Five: "Of the odd-numbered faces, exactly two tell the truth."
Six: "Lead cannot open the door."
Four metal keys hang nearby. You ponder, then use...
...the gold key.
...the silver key.
...the copper key.
...the lead key.
(Source: Darklands cluebook by MicroProse Software)

Four must be a liar because "knights" would never call themselves liars. Neither would knaves for that matter, at least not in an unqualified fashion. However the statement is a little more complex than that: "Face Six and myself are the only two liars" really means that there are other liars than Four. (Six is not a liar because Four said Six is a liar.)

If Five is a "knight" then Three and Five are the two "knights" of the odd-numbered faces and the choices are restricted to silver and copper. (One is a "knave" and Six, previously established as a "knight", has said that lead cannot open the door.) If, on the other hand, Five is a "knave", then only one of the odd-numbered faces can be a "knight": "exactly two" is ruled out and "all three" is contradicted by the assumption that Five is a "knave". In this case, Three is the only "knight" and lead and gold are still both ruled out. Whether Five is a "knight" or a "knave", the choices are still limited to silver and copper and One is a "knave".

Having established all of this, Two must also be a "knave", because Two claims that One speaks the truth, meaning that the copper key opens the door.

Darklands Puzzle #9

A door blocks the path. Its inscription reads:
FACES ALWAYS LIE OR ALWAYS SPEAK TRUTH.
TOUCH ONE KNOB TO OPEN THE DOOR.
On the wall are six numbered faces, who speak:
One: "Copper cannot open the door."
Two: "Face One speaks the truth. Face Four speaks truth. Gold cannot open the door."
Three: "All odd-numbered faces speak truth."
Four: "If Face Three lies, silver opens the door."
Five: "Gold opens the door."
Six: "Black is white. Copper opens the door."
Upon the door are four metal knobs. You touch...
...the gold.
...the silver.
...the copper.
...the lead.
(Source: Darklands cluebook by MicroProse Software)

The first clue is a gimme: Six is claiming black is white and is therefore a liar. This means that the copper knob does not open the door. This means that One speaks the truth. In turn, Two must speak the truth, because all faces are perfectly uniform about lying or speaking the truth. Four, who has already been established as a truth-teller, says that, if Three lies, silver opens the door. Five is lying, meaning that Three's claim is a lie. Therefore the silver knob opens the door.

Darklands Puzzle #8

The path is blocked by an iron door. Carved about it are the words:
ONE HEAD INVARIABLY SPEAKS TRUTH.
THE OTHER HEADS ALWAYS LIE.
Embossed on the door are four metal heads. They speak:
Gold: "Yesterday, Hootvin said that the gold knob opened the door."
Silver: "The copper head speaks the truth."
Copper: "I am not Hootvin."
Lead: "Naturally not, for I am Hootvin."
The door has two knobs, gold and silver. One opens the door, the other is probably (is. ed.) a trap. You press...
...the gold knob.
...the silver knob.
(Source: Darklands cluebook by MicroProse Software)

Silver is obviously lying because only one head can speak the truth. This means that Copper is also lying and is therefore Hootvin. Lead is lying because he can't be Hootvin. (Presumably there is only one Hootvin.) This leaves Gold as the sole truth-teller but there is a caveat: Gold is relaying what Hootvin (an inveterate liar) said. This means that the silver knob opens the door.

Wednesday, March 6, 2019

Darklands Puzzle #6

The path is blocked by a grim iron door. To one side is a golden statue of a dwarf. On the other is a silver statue of a dwarf. Embossed on the door are the words:
ONE STATUE ALWAYS LIES.
ONE STATUE ALWAYS SPEAKS TRUTH.
As you ponder this, they speak.
The gold statue says, "To open the door, touch the statue which speaks truth."
The silver statue says, "To open the door, touch the statue which lies." Which statue is right? The wrong statue may (will. ed.) release a dwarf trap! You think carefully, then...
...touch the gold statue.
...touch the silver statue.
(Source: Darklands cluebook by MicroProse Software)

Assume first that Gold is the "knight" of the pair. This means that one would touch Gold. But this assumption may not be warranted and on the other hand it may be the case that Gold  is the "knave" of the pair. In this case, Gold is really telling the player to touch the statue that doesn't tell the truth (i.e. lies). And, in this case, Silver (i.e. the "knight") is fully willing to back up the tacit statement of the Gold: touch the statue that is a dirty liar (i.e. Gold). In any case, one should touch Gold. And pray that it doesn't start to melt like the one in the Hobbit films.
Dies ist nicht dein Königreich. Dies ist Zwergenland, dies ist Zwergengold. Und wir bekommen unsere Rache!

Darklands Puzzle #5

Here is a dark iron door. Carved in it are:
ONLY ONE KNOB OPENS THE DOOR.
ONLY ONE STATEMENT IS WHOLLY TRUE.
Four knobs are on the door, of gold, silver, copper and lead. Four statements are on the wall nearby:
  1. The gold knob opens the door.
  2. The lead knob opens the door.
  3. Neither the silver knob nor the gold knob open the door.
  4. The lead knob does not open the door.
Only one statement is true. But which? Only one knob opens the door. Which?
...gold.
...silver.
...copper.
...Iead.
(Source: Darklands cluebook by MicroProse Software)

The cluebook makes the very helpful suggestion of starting with focusing attention on statements #2 and #4. Only one of them can be true. If statement #2 is true then statement #3 is also, true, which contradicts the stipulations of the puzzle. This means that #4 is the only wholly true statement out of the lot. Because statement #3 is a logical conjunction, one of its operands is permitted to be true while the other is false, making it not wholly true. Statement #1 does not have this luxury and is therefore required to be false. This means that the silver knob opens the door.

Darklands Puzzle #4

(Yes, #4, I didn't say I was doing them all.)
Here is a grim iron door inscribed:
ONLY ONE KNOB OPENS THE DOOR.
EACH METAL'S STATEMENTS ARE EITHER BOTH TRUE OR BOTH FALSE.
One the floor are six statements and three metal knobs, each of a
different metal.
Gold: Tifsyn's only son is Hardgrep.
Gold: The gold knob opens the door.
Silver: The gold knob opens the door.
Silver: The silver knob does not open the door.
Copper: Tifsyn's only son is Gymer.
Copper: The gold statements are both true.
You press...
...gold.
...silver.
...copper.
(Source: Darklands cluebook by MicroProse Software)

Well let's see here: Copper claims that Gold's statements are both true. This mean's that Tifsyn's only son is Hardgrep. But Copper also claims that Tifsyn's only son is Gymer. We have a contradiction! Because what Copper is saying in one instance cannot possibly be true, as stipulated by the puzzle, both of Copper's statements are false. This means that Gold's statements are both also false. Where does that put Silver? Well Gold and Silver both claim the gold knob opens the door. That means that everyone here is a liar. Very sad! The silver knob opens the door.